The Defender Dilemma: Matt Roberts Discusses Swans Fantasy Potential

Fantasy

Selecting defenders for AFL Fantasy Classic is proving to be quite a task. There seems to be no guaranteed approach to finding the right configuration, and true must-have players are scarce.

The Traders have set their sights on Jayden Short (DEF, $825,000), albeit with some reservations. They’re banking on him returning to his past form, where he averaged over 90, as he takes the lead in the Tigers’ youthful defence.

Matt Roberts (DEF, $780,000) presents great value, especially after his impressive conclusion to the 2024 season, during which he clinched the Michael Barlow Medal for Cash Cow of the Year with an average of 104 in his final seven matches.

Roberts joins Roy, Calvin, and Warnie to discuss his pre-season and faces the tough question: will he include himself in AFL Fantasy Classic?

In the Official AFL Fantasy Podcast, Roberts mentions that Callum Mills (DEF, $759,000) is a definitive choice, considering he’s transitioned fully into a midfield role where he has had an average of over 110 across the previous two seasons. He also highlights some emerging players who could become valuable assets in Fantasy Classic this year.

The Traders review defenders on their radar for both Classic and Draft formats, covering premium options at the top, mid-range value players, and essential cash cows.

Catch the AFL Fantasy Podcast with The Traders on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.

Episode guide

0:30 – Roy emphasises how defenders will distinguish the top teams
4:50 – Jayden Short and Callum Mills as the early defensive certainties
6:40 – Is Keidean Coleman a viable pick?
8:05 – Roy reveals his top defenders, led by Harry Sheezel
11:00 – You’ll get value with Jack Sinclair
13:50 – Alternative value picks to consider
18:05 – Sam De Koning is a player to watch for his role
20:30 – Rookie watchlist
25:25 – Matt Roberts discusses his pre-season
28:20 – Positioning of Callum Mills
30:15 – Dean Cox’s slight changes
31:30 – Affordable Swans worth considering
33:50 – Fantasy Draft reflections
37:35 – Social media queries – connect with @AFLFantasy on X, @aflfantasy on Instagram, and like the Official AFL Fantasy Facebook page
43:05 – Insights on Arie Schoenmaker

For expert insight from The Traders during the pre-season, visit the Fantasy Hub. Follow AFL Fantasy on X and Instagram, and ‘like’ the Facebook page to engage in discussions.