OPINION: While Bruno Fernandes may have his flaws, Manchester United would struggle immensely without him.

When considering the long list of signings Manchester United have made since the departure of Sir Alex Ferguson, it’s hard to overlook the impact of Bruno Fernandes.

Fernandes is a player rich in talent, driven by a winning mentality, a sense of accountability, and an unyielding ability to perform when his team needs him most—truly a complete package. While his animated gestures and on-field behaviour may frustrate some, many view him as a standout player in a club otherwise bogged down by mediocrity.

Thus, when former Manchester United captain Roy Keane critiqued Fernandes‘ leadership and performances on the The Overlap podcast, it seemed to undermine all that Fernandes has accomplished and continues to contribute to the club. Is the Portuguese international an ideal captain? No, he isn’t, but does he need to be?

If Fernandes were to play for a club with just one seasoned leader who thrived in the role of captain, he would likely blend in as just another player.

Fernandes’ main challenge has been having to assume leadership responsibilities in the absence of established leaders—taking on a role that shouldn’t really fall on his shoulders.

He does exhibit commendable captaincy qualities; he leads by example, his dedication is exceptional, and he takes responsibility following disappointing performances.

While his flailing arms and pouting can appear counterproductive, one must appreciate the frustration he experiences playing alongside teammates with a notably lower football understanding.

The creative midfielder could potentially enhance his game by concentrating on what he does best: crafting chances and scoring.

Nevertheless, as a true leader should, Fernandes has risen to the occasion, bearing the weight of responsibility that comes with the captain’s armband.

He also embodies a rare humility for someone of his calibre and consistently fronts up about his less-than-stellar performances.

When asked about Keane’s remarks, Fernandes’ response epitomises his character.

“It’s not pleasant to hear such things about oneself; I believe no one enjoys it. However, at the same time, it serves as motivation and encourages reflection on areas for improvement,” he stated.

“You have to approach it positively and consider whether there’s potential for growth. I greatly respect Roy Keane, as he was one of the best captains this club has ever had and a phenomenal player who achieved nearly everything possible here.”

“It’s just his perspective on my abilities as both a player and a captain. I must respect that. I strive to be the best captain, person, and teammate I can be every day.”

“I endeavour to lead by example in all aspects, both during training sessions and on the pitch.”

“Certainly, not everyone will appreciate my approach or think the same way. I respect everyone’s opinions and acknowledge that there is still considerable room for improvement in my game and leadership.”

Fernandes could have reacted in many different ways, yet he chose to respond with respect while demonstrating his eagerness to learn and grow as both a player and captain. It’s evident that Keane’s criticisms hit him hard, but he faced them with strength, turning that feedback into motivation.

Since then, Fernandes’ form has soared, resembling the player who arrived at the club with an insatiable hunger to score and an uncanny ability to make a difference in crucial moments. His striking performances against Fulham, Arsenal, and Real Sociedad exemplify this perfectly. His goal against Fulham was both stunning and essential, forcing the match into extra time when United had scarcely threatened.

He scored a phenomenal opener against Arsenal, giving United an unexpected lead despite being outplayed. Lastly, his two penalties against Sociedad may have been straightforward, yet they proved to be significant. Fernandes seems unfazed by pressure.

The ‘Portuguese Magnifico’ has found his stride at a crucial point in the season as Ruben Amorim’s men chase a faint hope of Europa League glory. Should Manchester United gain traction under Amorim, expect Fernandes to be at the nucleus of their efforts.

If that isn’t exemplary leadership, then what is?

Might it be time for Fernandes’ teammates to rise to the occasion and help secure him the Champions League football he rightfully deserves? Because United would undoubtedly struggle without their captain, and if they fail to qualify for European competition next year, Fernandes would be justified in seeking new opportunities.

With all his contributions and his stature as one of the finest in his role, it would be a shame if Fernandes concluded his career without a trophy-laden cabinet.