The question of which achievement holds more weight – the Premiership or the Championship – has been a longstanding topic of discussion among football enthusiasts.
This week on Total A-Leagues, the debate was reignited.
Go Media Stadium was alive with celebrations last weekend as Auckland FC revelled alongside their passionate supporters after securing the Premiership Plate in their inaugural season.
During the episode, Sydney Morning Herald sports journalist Vince Rugari and former Socceroos winger Tommy Oar engaged in a discussion about whether the Premiership Plate has gained more respect in recent times, particularly in light of how fiercely competitive the top six teams have been this season.
“I believe that the importance we place on that trophy and finishing at the top of the standings in Australia has certainly grown over the years,” Rugari stated at the onset of the discussion.
FEATURE INTERVIEW: Australian wonderkid shares ‘one club I want to play for’ after dispelling Google myth
“If we look back to ten years ago, the term ‘Minor Premiership’ was often used to refer to it. That phrase has largely fallen out of use now.
“Many now understand it as a substantial accolade.
“The Federation and the governing body of the league acknowledge this as well by granting the winner direct qualification into the Asian Champions League.
“While Auckland won’t benefit from that this season, it clearly illustrates the significance of the title.
WELCOME TO WELLINGTON: Phoenix coach discusses the thrill of facing a global phenomenon in pre-season
Rugari continued, “However, we still tend to view the team that secures the A-League title as the ultimate winners when it comes to the Grand Finals…”
Former Brisbane Roar, Central Coast Mariners, and Macarthur Bulls midfielder Oar chimed in, arguing that the finals series offers a unique aspect to Australian sport.
“I believe it’s rooted in our sporting culture, and I don’t foresee that changing anytime soon. The excitement generated during the final series is unparalleled.
“It’s a distinctive characteristic when comparing football internationally, and it’s part of what makes this sport so special. We’ve witnessed teams, like Kevin Muscat’s squad, clinch the grand final title after finishing fourth in the league, which was quite unexpected.
“While it’s great for teams to be acknowledged for winning the Premiership, I’m a huge advocate for the finals. I absolutely love it.
“Although it might not be the most straightforward or fair method of rewarding the top team, it’s all about the thrill and entertainment, and that’s the essence of sport.”
Rugari added, “I believe we’re successfully striking a balance that respects both elements, especially considering Australia’s sports history and culture. We have a finals series, and we’ve always had one.
“This isn’t merely an Australian sporting element; it’s a long-standing aspect of Australian football.”
“It’s remarkable that we haven’t seen scenes like Auckland lifting the Premiership Plate until quite recently.
WEEKEND PREVIEW: Key details for Round 29 of the Isuzu UTE A-League
“As far as I recall, there have been instances when the Premiership Plate was presented during half-time of a finals match…”
Oar concluded, “And for fans, having a day to celebrate before, during, and after the game with the team – it’s all about that communal experience. It’s fantastic to see the connection between Auckland’s supporters and the club in their first season, especially given the positive atmosphere and the high-quality football they’ve been playing. They absolutely deserve this success.”
Compiled by SportArena.com.au.
Fanpage: SportArena.com.au.
LiveScore – Live Sports Results & Odds.
